Skip to main content

By purchasing tickets to any La Jolla Music Society event, you agree to our COVID-19 Policy. Learn more.

REVIEW: The Academy of St. Martin in the Fields with Joshua Bell Returns to San Diego

San Diego Story

Kenneth Herman
March 15, 2022


While San Diego performing arts organizations are hastily restoring their seasons now that the lockdowns of the COVID pandemic have receded, one local tradition has survived unscathed. The acclaimed British chamber orchestra the Academy of St. Martin in the Fields that has visited San Diego every other March since 2018 with their resident violin virtuoso and conductor Joshua Bell performed Monday at San Diego Civic Theatre .

Of course, the Academy was most fortunate to have played in San Diego’s Jacobs Music Center in early March of 2020, just a week before COVID brought all live performance around the globe to a halt. Due to the current renovations at the Jacobs Music Center, the La Jolla Music Society (LJMS) chose to present the Academy in Civic Theatre, where the San Diego Symphony is also presenting a number of its concerts during the Jacobs Music Center renovation.

In 2013 the LJMS presented the Academy in the Balboa Theatre downtown, and based on performances in these three venues, I find Civic Theatre the least conducive to the size and sonority of the Academy of St. Martin in the Fields. Like their conductor soloist, the Academy’s 24 string players produce a lithe, silvery timbre which certainly contributes to the lauded precision and focus of their impeccable ensemble, but these players sounded underpowered in the capacious 3,000-seat Civic Theatre.

Bell and the Academy opened with J. S. Bach’s Violin Concerto in A Minor, BWV 1041, which they launched with the frisky exuberance of a generic Vivaldi concerto. The Academy strings’ interpretation benefited from the graceful drive of Bell’s soaring traceries, and when Bach’s contrapuntal complexity kicked in, they coped with ease. It was during Bell’s hushed but aptly luxuriant account of the middle movement cantilena that I noticed that the harpsichord was missing from the Civic Theatre stage. The program lists John Constable as the Academy’s Principal Piano and Harpsichord–and we did hear him play the piano in the Samuel Barber Violin Concerto that followed the Bach offering–but where was the harpsichord, a requisite component of every Baroque basso continuo? Bell’s panache in the Bach Concerto’s vibrant final movement was matched by the orchestra’s robust but highly disciplined ensemble.

Bell graced the program with a second concerto, Samuel Barber’s 1939 Violin Concerto, after his ubiquitous “Adagio for Strings” the most frequently programmed of the mid-20th century American composer’s catalogue. There is an undeniably wistful yearning quality about Barber’s most successful melodies–and the Violin Concerto is full of them–and Bell gave them their apt poignancy. Although we expect virtuosos to sail through the technical challenges of the concerto finale’s daunting moto perpetuo, accomplishing this is still a feat, and Bell carried off his assignment with admirable flair.

No Academy touring program is complete without a Beethoven Symphony, and this year’s offering was Beethoven’s Third, the “Eroica.” In its day, its length, bold themes, and jarring modulations riled audiences accustomed to the tailored predictability of Haydn’s 100-plus symphonies, but what sounded unconventional in 1803 has become the hallowed Beethoven trademark. The Academy under Bell’s direction from the Concertmaster’s position gave a compelling account of the “Eroica,” displaying an enviable balance of passion and precision. Hearing an early Beethoven symphony played by an ensemble of this size–24 strings and 14 winds–gives a more satisfying sonic realization of what Beethoven intended, even though the Academy is not a period orchestra, because orchestral ensembles in the composer’s day were much closer to the size of what we call chamber orchestra rather than the 70 — 100 member contemporary symphony orchestra.

In the Academy’s case, the sound of their wind sections gracefully blended into the string sound, rather than competing against a battalion of 50-plus strings. In the second movement, the funeral march remained somber without suggesting a dirge, and in the third movement, the buoyant calls of the horn section added to the euphoric dash of this very rapid Scherzo. The exuberance of the Academy’s last movement brought the evening to an appropriately joyous conclusion.

This concert was presented by the La Jolla Music Society on March 14, 2022, in San Diego Civic Theatre in downtown San Diego.